Journal under attack over controversial paper on gm food nature. Arpad pusztai the sacked scientist whose work has been at the centre of the gm food controversy for the past 8 months. Eric drexler and arpad pusztai, this is the first global overview of the state of nanotech and society in europe, the usa, japan and canada, examining the ethics, the. The editor of the prestigious journal lancet said, it is astounding that the us food and drug administration has not changed their stance on genetically modified food adopted in 1992. Plant lectins are extensively used as tools and as bioactiveproteins in different areas of biomedical and biological research.
Educators have permission to reprint articles for classroom use. Its editor, richard horton, told the guardian, there was intense pressure on the lancet from all quarters, including the royal society, to suppress publication. Midtvedt cites the editorial remark made recently in the lancet when that journal published some of the work by arpad pusztai on rats fed lectincontaining. Fifteen years ago dr arpad pusztai was mercilessly attacked by many prominent members of the scientific establishment, forced out of his job at the rowett institute in aberdeen on grounds of malpractice and made to look on as his research team was dismantled. Pusztai fed genetically modified potatoes to mice in the experiment and noticed horrific results. Thank you for this wellwritten letter to the editor of huffington post.
Arpad pusztai was one of the first scientists to raise concerns about the safety of genetically modified foods. Consumption of diets containing raw soya beans glycine. Effect of diets containing genetically modified potatoes expressing galanthus nivalis lectin on rat small intestine. Effect of diets containing genetically modified potatoes. Scienceasculture,volume11,number1,2002 gmfoodsafety. Pusztais potatoes is genetic modification the culprit. Scientists avert new gmo crisis nature biotechnology. The handbook of plant lectins provides a comprehensive yet conciseoverview of the biochemical properties, carbohydratebindingspecificity, biological activities and applications of most of thecurrently known plant lectins. Arpad pusztai announced to the world via the media that his research on rats showed that genetically engineered plants could be dangerous to human health. Seeds of deception institute for responsible technology. The ecologist v30 no2 p269 ap 2000 the magazine publisher is the holder of this article and it is reproduced with permission. Aquaponics usaworld newsletter may is part of our series. Editor s reply stanley ewen and arpad pusztai s research letter was published on grounds of scientific merit, as well as public interest.
Open letter to editor of huffington post on removal of vaccine related content. Analysis of pusztai study on gm potatoes and their effect on rats. The fdas defense that the bleeding stomachs did not come from the flavr savr diet was also an exercise in faulty science. When scientist arpad pusztai reported that genetically modified gm foods caused serious health problems in rats, he was a hero at his prestigious uk institute for two days. A present day account on the safety of food derived from gm crops. Arpad pusztai personal communication in 1999 arpad pusztai and stanley ewen published their results in the lancet link below. In the late 1990s, pusztai, a respected molecular biologist, conducted research on gm potatoes for the rowett institute in scotland.
Oct 01, 2012 dr arpad pusztai evoked world wide media attention in august 1998, when he said in british tv that he would not eat genetically engineered food because of the insufficient testing procedures they. He is a world expert on plant lectins, authoring 270 papers and three books on the subject in 1998, arpad pusztai publicly announced that the results of his research showed feeding genetically modified potatoes to rats had. Arpad pusztai academic dictionaries and encyclopedias. He had been an enthusiastic supporter of genetic engineering, working on cutting edge safety research with genetically modified gm foods. Further reproduction of this article in violation of the is prohibited. Smith, author of the bestseller seeds of deception. Aquaponics usaworld newsletter may is part of our. To open the lessons pdf file, you need adobe acrobat reader. Your decision to publish the research of stanley ewen and arpad pusztai1 breaks unfortunate new ground for a scientific journal. One of the papers authors, arpad pusztai, was suspended last year from the rowett research institute in aberdeen for making claims about the lack of safety of. Arpad pusztai, a scientist, nutritionist, biochemist, and molecular biologist, was one of the first to voice concerns about safety as it pertains to gmo foods. Biotech companies are peddling dangerous propaganda about.
He is considered the worlds foremost expert on plant lectins, and is the author of 270 papers and three books on the subject in 1998 pusztai publicly announced that the results of his research show. Arpad pusztai was a renowned scientist in the the world of experimental biology. Biological divide the guardian 18 january 2008 daily mail article detailling the events surrounding arpad pusztai s sacking effect of diets containing genetically modified potatoes expressing galanthus nivalis lectin on rat small intestine s. I agree that it is important to keep a paper trail of logical responses. The potatoes were genetically altered to produce lectins, natural insecticides, to protect them. Arpad pusztai pronounced poostie dared to speak the truth. Pusztai and a colleague submitted their paper to a renowned scientific journal, the lancet. Lancet editor defends decision to publish gm research paper ncbi. Scienticand institutionalissues arpadpusztai jlectinstudy in1995thethenscottishofceofagriculture,environmentand. Lancet editor defends decision to publish gm research paper. Pusztai, born in hungary, received his degree in chemistry in budapest and his b. Arpad pusztai an original article en espanol articlehighlights genetically modified gm crops and food are being grown and consumed by the public, even though. The policy is that genetically modified crops will receive the same consideration for potential health risks as any other new crop plant.
In his commentary, degler described arpad pusztais infamous study concerning gmos potential carcinogenic effects. September 1930 in budapest, ungarn ist ein ungarisch britischer. Arpad pusztai the sacked scientist whose work has been at the centre of the gm. Dr arpad pusztai evoked world wide media attention in august 1998, when he said in british tv that he would not eat genetically engineered food because of the insufficient testing procedures they. Mar 14, 2006 on august 10th, 1998, arpad pusztai of the rowett research institute in aberdeen, scotland appeared on the british tv show world in action. Arpad pusztai born 8 september 1930 is a hungarianborn biochemist and nutritionist who spent 36 years at the rowett research institute in aberdeen, scotland. Risk, ethics and law by geoffrey hunt editor in chm, fb3, rtf download ebook. A survey of the nutritional and haemagglutination properties of legume seeds generally available in the uk volume 50 issue 2 george grant, linda j. An unamed member of the royal society allegedly put strong pressure on the lancet not to publish, including a threatening phone call to the lancet editor.
Pdf genetically modified foods and the pusztai affair. Archived from the original pdf on 27 september 2011. The uk government was about to change all that, and hungarian born chemist dr. Effect of diets containing genetically modified potatoes expressing galanthus nivalis lectin on rat small intestine by sw ewen and arpad pusztai. Massive conspiracy uncoveredyour health is at risk skywatchtv.
One of the papers authors, arpad pusztai, was suspended last year from. Editor s reply stanley ewen and arpad pusztais research letter was published on grounds of scientific merit, as well as public interest. Fifteen years too late when will pusztai get an apology from those who destroyed his career. Open letter to editor of huffington post on removal of. He has published over 300 scientific articles, authored or edited twelve books and collaborated with other leading researchers around the globe. On august 10th, 1998, arpad pusztai of the rowett research institute in aberdeen, scotland appeared on the british tv show world in action. The paper reporting research on gm potatoes work that most scientists dismissed as fatally flawed is now published in the lancet, along with a lengthy explanation of the reasons behind the decision from the editor, richard horton.
Journal under attack over controversial paper on gm food. The editors of the lancet published an editorial in may 1999 in which they denounced all. According to, the experimental design was seriously flawed. Pusztai, a researcher at the rowett institute in scotland, and colleagues had genetically modified potatoes by inserting a gene from small flowers. Consumption of diets containing raw soya beans glycine max, kidney beans phaseolus vulgaris, cowpeas vigna unguiculata or lupin seeds lupinus angustifolius by rats for up to 700 days.
He is considered the worlds foremost expert on plant lectins, and is the author of 270 papers and three books on the subject. Protein scientist arpad pusztai went public with the initial results of unpublished research he was conducting at the rowett institute in aberdeen, scotland, investigating the possible effects of genetically modified potatoes upon rats. Pdf media coverage of genetically modified organisms. He spent thirtysix years at the rowett research institute in aberdeen, scotland, until statements about the negative effects of gmo foods on lab rats resulted in criticism and. Arpad pusztai conducted his experiments on gm potatoes. Jun 01, 2009 arpad pusztai was one of the first scientists to raise concerns about the safety of genetically modified foods. In the course of the interview, he announced that his experiments showed that rats fed a diet of potatoes expressing a gene coding for a snowdrop sugarbinding protein showed stunted growth and reduced. Arpad pusztai, the worlds foremost gm protein expert, who emphasized, no further releases of gmcrops must be allowed. Endnotes for seeds of deception introduction 1 stuart laidlaw, starlink fallout could cost billions, the toronto star, january 9, 2001 2 robert cohen, milk, the deadly poison, argus publishing, englewood cliffs, new jersey, 1998, p. Pusztai claimed that the genetically modified potatoes had stunted growth and repressed the rats. On august 10th, 1998, arpad pusztai of the rowett research institute in. Including contributions by renowned figures such as roland clift, k.
An introduction to the science by john fagan, michael antoniou, and claire robinson part 1. Antibiotics in your corn by sheldon krimsky and timo assmuth 3. His research was publicised just as gm foods were first appearing in shops and many people were. Ewen and arpad pusztai claimed to have conducted experiments revealing variations in the thickness of intestinal linings of rats when they were fed diets containing either gm or nongm potatoes. The work was published the following year in the british medical journal the lancet. But to his surprise, his experiments showed that gm foods were inherently dangerous. Feb 28, 2006 on august 10th, 1998, arpad pusztai of the rowett research institute in aberdeen, scotland appeared on the british tv show world in action.
The medical journal the lancet has been criticized by britains royal society for publishing a paper on genetically modified gm potatoes by controversial author arpad pusztai. Review of data on possible toxicity of gm potatoes. Pusztai also pointed out that the experimental tomatoes were grown at different locations and harvested at different times, which further increases the variability of results. Put simply, the lancet has placed politics andtabloid sensationalism above its responsibility to report and assess new science. Consumption of diets containing raw soya beans glycine max. He is a world expert on plant lectins, authoring 270 papers and three books on the subject. Lancet chief editor richard horton published the paper. The pusztai affair is a controversy that began in 1998. Pusztai claimed that the genetically modified potatoes had stunted growth and repressed the.
Influence of genetically modified soya on the birthweight and survival of. Child obesity and health download the full report in pdf format. Pusztai published social research social trends analysis. Fifteen years too late when will pusztai get an apology. The editor of the lancet, dr richard horton, this week defended his decision to publish a controversial paper on genetically modified foods as absolutely the right thing to do amid continued criticisms that he had simply fuelled public confusion over the issue. Arpad pusztai was the first senior scientist to question the effects of genetically modified foods. This is a point succinctly made by david whitehouse, bbc news onlines science editor. Fifteen years ago dr arpad pusztai was mercilessly attacked by many prominent members of the scientific establishment, forced out of his job at the rowett institute in aberdeen on grounds of malpractice and made to look on as his research.
1018 984 325 1453 814 561 497 408 161 1500 1425 609 38 1025 1245 1134 1037 742 1331 209 1343 1250 99 91 811 163 707 520 659 191 20 794 493 1429 212 540 459 134 16 614 431 1088 1259